投稿问答最小化  关闭

万维书刊APP下载

如何巧妙回应小修与大修审稿意见:技巧与模板

2025/4/3 14:54:51  阅读:283 发布者:

投稿SCI期刊时,审稿环节至关重要,它能显著提升论文质量和学术水平。审稿意见通常分为小修和大修,作者需据此对论文进行针对性修改。以下是针对小修和大修的审稿意见回复模板,帮助作者高效回应审稿人关切,优化稿件。

小修订的回复

1. 感谢审稿人的建议:

We appreciate the thoughtful review and constructive feedback provided by the reviewers.

(我们感谢审稿人提供的深思熟虑的审查和建设性的反馈。)

2. 明确接受建议:

We agree with the reviewers' suggestions and will incorporate the recommended changes into the manuscript.

(我们同意审稿人的建议,并将建议的修改融入到稿件中。)

3. 逐条回应:

Reviewer 1 suggested improving the clarity of Figure 3. We will revise the figure to enhance readability, and we appreciate the valuable suggestion.

(审稿人1建议提高图3的清晰度。我们将修改图表以增强可读性,并感谢这宝贵的建议。)

4. 展示修改:

In response to the comment about the literature review, we have added references XXXX et al. (2022) and provided a brief discussion, as suggested (see revised pages 4-5).

(针对文献综述的评论,我们已添加了XXXX等人(2022)的参考文献,并按建议提供了简要的讨论(请参见修订后的第4-5页)。)

5. 再次感谢:

We sincerely appreciate the time and effort invested by the reviewers in evaluating our manuscript. We look forward to any additional feedback or suggestions.

(我们由衷感谢审稿人在评估我们的手稿时所投入的时间和精力。我们期待任何额外的反馈或建议。)

大修订的回复

1. 理解审稿人的关切: 明确理解审稿人提出的主要问题,展示对问题的认知和解决的决心。

We appreciate the reviewers' thorough evaluation and recognize the major concerns raised regarding the clarity of our main argument and the completeness of the theoretical framework.

2. 接受建议并展望未来:表达接受审稿人建议并进行大修订的决心,并展望未来能够提供更丰富、详尽的证据支持。

We acknowledge the need for major revisions and are committed to addressing the highlighted issues comprehensively. We believe that these revisions will significantly strengthen our manuscript and provide a more robust foundation for our claims.

3. 详细说明修改计划:逐一说明将如何解决审稿人提出的每个主要问题,可以使用清晰的标题或编号。

3.1. Clarification of Main Argument:

We plan to restructure the Introduction and Discussion sections to provide a more lucid presentation of our main argument. Specific attention will be given to...

3.2. Enhancement of Theoretical Framework:

To address the concerns raised about the theoretical framework, we will conduct an in-depth literature analysis and incorporate relevant writings on...

4. 明确的时间表:提供一个明确的时间表,说明何时可以提交修订后的论文。

We aim to complete the major revisions by [specific date], and we will promptly resubmit the revised manuscript for your kind consideration.

5. 再次感谢: 在结尾再次感谢审稿人的耐心和指导,并期待进一步合作。

We are grateful for the invaluable feedback provided by the reviewers, and we look forward to the opportunity to improve our manuscript in response to their guidance.

其他SCI审稿意见回复

1.审稿人提出「图中需要补充比例尺」回复:

we have incorporated the requested scale bars to enhance the clarity of the images.

2.审稿人提出「部分图片没有显著性差异」回复:

we have denoted significant differences with asterisks in the figures.

3.审稿人提出「补充缩写词的全称」回复:

Addressing the reviewer's comment, comprehensive descriptions for abbreviations like lHC, MTT, etc., have been added to the revised manuscript.

转自特诺科研微信公众号,仅作学习交流,如有侵权,请联系本站删除!


  • 万维QQ投稿交流群    招募志愿者

    版权所有 Copyright@2009-2015豫ICP证合字09037080号

     纯自助论文投稿平台    E-mail:eshukan@163.com