审稿人通常会有以下几类问题针对不同问题我们可以有不同的回答模板。
切记：一定展现出诚意，虚心回答，point by point，不要刻意回避某些问题。
补充实验/仿真模拟类：
这类问题通常都很复杂，切忌回避问题。真的要做到点到点回答。你所要回避的问题审稿人都能发现。所以即使我们现有条件解决不了，我们也要向审稿人承认。不要自欺欺人。做科研还是要严谨，实在不行拒稿就换一家期刊。
补充实验符合理论预期，见往期内容。
补充实验不符合理论预期
注意：引用参考文献来说明情况
As suggested by the referee, we have tried our best to verify XXX by____. However, no ___ signal has been detected in our synthesis system. Other researchers also found that it is very difficult to obtain a well-resolved hyperfine structure for ___. As suggested in the literature, ____; Some researchers even think that it is impossible to obtain a well-resolved hyperfine structure by ___.
（参考自：知乎：一篇标准的审稿意见回复（Response to reviewer）是什么样的？- 知乎 (zhihu.com)）
3. 实验/仿真条件不允许
a）注意：引用参考文献遇到同样的问题，未解决
Unfortunately, due to the limitations in our experimental or simulation setup, we were unable to carry out the suggested experiment as recommended by the referee. This challenge is not unique to our study; in fact, similar constraints have been reported in the literature by other researchers. For example, in a study by [Author et al., Year], it was noted that the experimental conditions restricted the ability to conduct a certain type of analysis. Given the constraints of our current resources and capabilities, we were unable to overcome these limitations to perform the requested experiment. Despite this setback, we believe that our study still provides valuable insights and contributes meaningfully to the existing body of knowledge in this field.
"Regrettably, due to the constraints of our experimental resources, we were unable to conduct the proposed experiment as suggested. Similar challenges have been documented in the literature, as highlighted in a study by [Author et al., Year], where limitations in experimental conditions hindered certain analyses. While we acknowledge the importance of the recommended experiment, we hope that our current findings still provide valuable insights into the topic."
"Given the limitations in our experimental setup, we were unable to carry out the specific experiment requested by the referee. This issue is not uncommon in this field, as evidenced by previous studies such as [Author et al., Year], which faced similar constraints due to equipment or resource limitations. Despite these challenges, we believe that our research contributes significantly to the understanding of the subject matter."
"Unfortunately, the constraints of our experimental facilities prevented us from conducting the experiment outlined by the referee. These limitations are consistent with those reported in the literature, as demonstrated in studies by [Author et al., Year], which also faced challenges in executing certain experiments. While we were unable to address this specific recommendation, we are confident in the validity and robustness of our current findings."
"Due to the restrictions in our experimental conditions, we were unable to carry out the suggested experiment as advised by the referee. This issue is a common limitation in research, as highlighted in the literature by [Author et al., Year], where similar constraints impacted the ability to perform certain analyses. Despite these limitations, we believe our study contributes valuable insights to the field."
"As a result of the limitations in our experimental setup, we were unable to execute the requested experiment. This challenge is not unique to our research; in fact, it has been documented in previous studies, such as [Author et al., Year], where similar constraints hindered the ability to conduct certain analyses. While we were unable to address this specific experiment, we remain confident in the significance of our current study and its contribution to the field."
b）参考文献中已经解决此类问题，我们需要引用其结论
"Based on previous studies, such as [Author et al., Year], it has been demonstrated that the constraints we encountered in our experimental setup are not unique and have been addressed in the literature. The study by [Author et al., Year] provides insights into similar limitations and their impact on experimental outcomes. Although we were unable to replicate the specific experiment suggested by the referee due to similar constraints, we are confident that our study's findings align with the conclusions drawn from previous research."
"As highlighted in [Author et al., Year], the challenges we faced in conducting the recommended experiment have been previously addressed in the literature. The study by [Author et al., Year] offers valuable insights into similar experimental limitations and their implications. While we were unable to perform the specific experiment due to these constraints, we trust that our research aligns with the conclusions drawn in prior studies."
"The limitations encountered in our experimental conditions have been acknowledged in previous research, such as [Author et al., Year], where similar constraints were addressed. The study by [Author et al., Year] offers a comprehensive analysis of these limitations and their effects on experimental outcomes. While we were unable to conduct the suggested experiment, we believe that our study's conclusions are consistent with the findings reported in the literature."
"Drawing on the findings of [Author et al., Year], we recognize that the challenges we faced in our experimental setup have previously been investigated and resolved in the literature. The study by [Author et al., Year] provides valuable insights into similar limitations and their impact on experimental outcomes. Despite our inability to carry out the recommended experiment, we are confident that our study's results are in line with the conclusions reached in prior research."
"As highlighted in previous research, such as [Author et al., Year], the constraints we encountered in our experimental conditions have been well-documented and addressed in the literature. The study by [Author et al., Year] offers a thorough examination of similar limitations and their implications. While we were unable to perform the specific experiment suggested by the referee, we trust that our study's results are consistent with the conclusions drawn from previous studies."
转自理论学习计算未来微信公众号，仅作学习交流，如有侵权，请联系本站删除！
